One of the problems of coral reefs loss (other than scuba divers seeing nothing cool when they dive) is that coral reefs is home for massive marine biodiversity. Destroyed and damaged coral reefs are usually stripped bare of their marine biodiversity as they are no longer favorable living conditions. Leaving the coral reefs alone without stress would allow coral reefs to auto-repair but the process ain't going to be completed in a day or two.
I mean if i were a fish, I wouldn't prefer the top reef too.
Image by: Catlin Seaview
Image by: Catlin Seaview
Airplane purposely sunk as an artificial reef.
Image by:
Reef balls made of concrete.
Image by: Reef ball foundation
Image by: Reef ball foundation
It's not all a bed of rose though. Artificial reefs has its issues too. The main component of reef balls is concrete and concrete synthesis produces carbon dioxide which contributes to global warming. Poor foresight and management when introducing such artificial reefs may backfire and cause further harm to reefs than benefits. For instance, the Osborne Tire Reef in the 1970s backfired completely. Instead of helping to augment two adjacent natural reefs, it ended up smothering and bashing into their fragile organisms. When bonds tying the tires broke, tires were washed onto beaches, both expensive and time consuming to clean up. (Stephen Harrigan,2011)
The tires were too mobile and corals could not manifest onto them.
I would think that artificial reefs is a great idea for a temporary solution before coral reefs regenerate themselves but much more study should have been done before the implementation to prevent later repurcussions.
References:
Harrigan, S.
(2011). Retrieved August 18, 2014, from
http://ngm.nationalgeographic.com/2011/02/artificial-reefs/harrigan-text/4
Wilkinson, C. (.
(2004). Status of coral reefs of the world. In Status of coral reefs of the
world (p. 301). Townsville, Queensland, Australia.: Australian Institute
of Marine Science.
Hi Eugene, good post on artificial reefs. As you mentioned, corals have the ability to recover when left undisturbed. But note this depends on the corals' level of tolerance and their species-specific adaptations to changing conditions. For instance, corals may be able to recover from medium-intensity coral bleaching if sea surface temperature is only raised for a short duration.
ReplyDeleteIn Singapore there has been work to encourage coral growth on sea walls as well. You're right to say it doesn't always work out, plus the process can be time-consuming and ultimately costly if management fails! It would be much better to protect the reefs in the first place... maybe by creating a Marine Protected Area.
More about artificial reefs here if you are interested: http://link.springer.com.libproxy1.nus.edu.sg/article/10.1023/A:1005759818050
Nice photos there, remember to credit the photographers if the pictures aren't taken by you.
Cheers,
Sarah